Is Tiffany’s micro-site better than Pinterest?

Thanks for reading! As you can see, we love to talk content. Get in touch to start a conversation about what great content can achieve for you.

Pinterest Engagement Board is generating a lot of interest and has even been cited as a leading traffic generator to retail sites (great infographic), surpassing Google+ and growing at leaps and bounds, especially among it’s target: women.

If it is the new coveted platform for gathering images based around topics of interest, then why did Tiffany’s decide not to use it for their “What Makes True Love” use curated photo campaign but rather rely on their own platform?


What makes Pinterest unique?

The earliest implementation of web browser favorites or bookmarks, came in 1993 (Mosiac). Since then we’ve changed their name from Bookmarks, to Shortcuts, to Favorites, and back again. Bookmarks allow consumers to manage favorite sites and in aggregate companies could start to make inferences about behaviors and likes for individuals and eventually for specific demographics.

Pinterest takes this bookmarking one step further by both showcasing something specifically worth pinning (not a whole webpage like with a bookmark) and by allowing users to create  visually stunning pinboards of things that they find interesting and deserving of being shared with others.

I personally like to think of Pinterest as a Facebook Like killer. Facebook Like allows a consumer to affiliate themselves with a brand in a positive way, but it centers on the the user. Pinterest allows a consumer to curate their interests, inspirations, and affinities in a manner that centers around the interest itself. In this case, the interest is “True Love” so why didn’t Tiffany’s simply use Pinterest to curate content from users?


Marketers are flocking to Pinterest and determining the best ways to utilize the platform to drive engagement. From contests, to focus groups, to cataloging like Nordstrom’s is doing, brands are attracted to experimenting within this very visual, very sharable platform. Using it as a source for inspiration, Pinterest is less about sharing with friends and more about sharing with those who share interests with you.

It seems then, that sharing True Love imagery and thoughts would be perfect for Pinterest. Tiffany’s does a great job really going beyond features and attributes to sell their products. In Rachel Lamb‘s Luxury Daily article, she quotes Chris Ramey, president of Affluent Insights who says “Selling product benefits is, today, a failed strategy. Tapping into your prospect’s deep-seated values and emotions is key.”

Tiffany's True Love is Everywhere
Tiffany's True Love is Everywhere

Tiffany’s “What Makes True Love” campaign certainly taps into those emotions and again aligns Tiffany’s directly with True Love and emotions. Their micro site covers True Love Stories, family heirlooms, songs by Paul McCartney and user curated photos inspired by sayings like “It was true love when…” The site also highlights the romance of New York by suggesting romantic places to go and seeing beloved places by their user generated content.

It’s clear Tiffany’s wanted features Pinterest couldn’t deliver. But, should Pinterest be considering an evolution?

If Pinterest included a map feature so others could see where interests are most concentrated then perhaps Pinterest could have a prominent offline influence as well. Knitting clubs could pop up in small neighborhoods where none existing in the past, or retail stores could then know where to open their next door. Pinterest can learn something from Tiffany’s addition of physical destinations and inclusion of their romantic suggestions in NYC. Pinterest can curate users interests for meaningful trend analysis and future data.

Having said that, I’d still have liked to see Tiffany’s use Pinterest and other Social Media platforms to further experiment with their initiatives and drive engagement on more widespread platforms.

3 Responses to “Is Tiffany’s micro-site better than Pinterest?”

  1. Allison

    Great post! I’m looking forward to seeing how Pinterest evolves. It’s a great visual tool. I hope too many people don’t abuse it by using it solely as a self promotion tool rather than what it is intended for: a visual bookmarking system, or inspiration board.

    I set up a Long’s Pinterest page a while ago and am careful not to pin too much of our jewelry. Rather, I pin bridal and vintage related images that are synonymous with our brand ‘personality.’

    You can see our pinboards here:

    • Rebecca Garnick Ast

      Thanks Allison.
      I think you are right. The tool has the potential to be overused. However I am hoping that if it evolves in the right way, then brands that participate are adding value and not simply self promoting.

      I like the approach Long’s Jewelers is using for picking and choosing what to pin. I hope to see it continue and look forward to hearing more about it’s success.


Comments are closed.